| Standings | Composite Schedule | |||||||
| Date | Away | Home | Time/Status | Links | |||
| Nov. 15 | N.C. Wesleyan | 73 | Wesley | 90 | Final | Box Box Box Recap Recap | |
| Methodist | 52 | Maryville (Tenn.) | 94 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Greensboro | 55 | Washington and Lee | 67 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Ferrum | 57 | Lynchburg | 77 | Final | Box | ||
| Chris. Newport | 72 | Roanoke | 73 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Nov. 16 | Frostburg St. | 75 | Shenandoah | 73 | Final - OT | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| Nov. 17 | Methodist | 72 | Guilford | 91 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap Recap | |
| Nov. 18 | Shenandoah | 81 | East. Mennonite | 87 | Final | Box Box Box Recap Recap Recap | |
| Randolph | 65 | Ferrum | 61 | Final | Box | ||
| Averett | 66 | Va. Wesleyan | 81 | Final | Box Box Recap | ||
| N.C. Wesleyan | 70 | N.C. Central | 85 | Final | |||
| Guilford | 76 | Greensboro | 49 | Final | |||
| Nov. 20 | Va. Wesleyan | 80 | Greensboro | 72 | Final | Box | |
| Maryland Bible | 91 | N.C. Wesleyan | 99 | Final - 2OT | |||
| 2009 Roger Taylor Invitational | |||||||
| Nov. 21 | Greensboro | 86 | Maryland Bible | 79 | Final | ||
| Va. Wesleyan | 78 | N.C. Wesleyan | 68 | Final | Box | ||
| 2009 Roger Taylor Invitational | |||||||
| Ferrum | 80 | Elmira | 55 | Final | |||
| @ NYU | |||||||
| Shenandoah | 58 | Randolph | 65 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Averett | 81 | East. Mennonite | 101 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| @ Bridgewater | |||||||
| Methodist | 58 | Gardner-Webb | 83 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Nov. 22 | Ferrum | 63 | Skidmore | 74 | Final | ||
| @ NYU Tip-Off Tourn. | |||||||
| Methodist | 85 | Oglethorpe | 87 | Final - OT | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Averett | 74 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 80 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Nov. 24 | Shenandoah | 76 | Marymount (Va.) | 72 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| N.C. Wesleyan | 75 | UNC Pembroke | 79 | Final - OT | Box Box Recap | ||
| Averett | 56 | Guilford | 81 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Va. Wesleyan | 69 | Chris. Newport | 58 | Final | Box | ||
| Nov. 25 | East. Mennonite | 81 | Ferrum | 66 | Final | Box Recap | |
| Nov. 27 | Me.-Presque Isle | 69 | Chris. Newport | 91 | Final | ||
| Nov. 28 | Otterbein | 58 | Greensboro | 59 | Final | ||
| Piedmont | 84 | Methodist | 78 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| N.C. Wesleyan | 79 | Hampden-Sydney | 90 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| 2nd Annual Southern Shootout | |||||||
| Southern Va. | 82 | Chris. Newport | 93 | Final - OT | Box Box Recap | ||
| CNU Invitational | |||||||
| Mary Washington | 68 | Shenandoah | 61 | Final | Box Box Box Recap Recap Recap | ||
| South Region Challenge @ Hampden-Sydney | |||||||
| Nov. 29 | Otterbein | 42 | Averett | 60 | Final | ||
| @ Greensboro, N.C. | |||||||
| N.C. Wesleyan | 77 | Mary Washington | 71 | Final | Recap | ||
| 2nd Annual Southern Shootout @ Hampden-Sydney, VA | |||||||
| Shenandoah | 71 | Hampden-Sydney | 79 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap Recap | ||
| South Region Challenge | |||||||
| Piedmont | 59 | Greensboro | 61 | Final | |||
| Nov. 30 | Emory & Henry | 72 | Ferrum | 76 | Final | ||
| Dec. 1 | Methodist | 66 | Va. Wesleyan | 83 | Final | Box Recap Recap | |
| Dec. 2 | Southern Va. | 82 | Shenandoah | 79 | Final | Box Box Box Box Recap Recap Recap | |
| Guilford | 83 | N.C. Wesleyan | 66 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Emory & Henry | 59 | Greensboro | 75 | Final | |||
| Dec. 3 | Maryland Bible | 56 | Chris. Newport | 101 | Final | ||
| Dec. 5 | Greensboro | 85 | LaGrange | 69 | Final | ||
| Washington and Lee | 61 | Averett | 58 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Lancaster Bible | 63 | Ferrum | 73 | Final | |||
| Methodist | 75 | Salisbury | 87 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Optimist Classic (Hampden-Sydney, Methodist, Ramapo) | |||||||
| Dec. 6 | Methodist | 117 | Ramapo | 129 | Final - 2OT | Box Recap | |
| @ Salisbury, Md. | |||||||
| Dec. 12 | Shenandoah | 78 | Va. Wesleyan | 90 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| Salisbury | 65 | Chris. Newport | 71 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| CNU Classic | |||||||
| Dec. 13 | Mary Washington | 72 | Greensboro | 65 | Final | Recap | |
| Lynchburg | 74 | Chris. Newport | 73 | Final - OT | |||
| Wooster | 87 | N.C. Wesleyan | 69 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| @ Ashland, Va. | |||||||
| Dec. 14 | N.C. Wesleyan | 87 | Alvernia | 81 | Final | ||
| @ Randolph-Macon | |||||||
| Stevenson | 67 | Shenandoah | 84 | Final | Box Box Box Recap Recap Recap | ||
| Maryville (Tenn.) | 87 | Averett | 71 | Final | |||
| Dec. 15 | Ferrum | 61 | Piedmont | 53 | Final | ||
| Dec. 16 | Marymount (Va.) | 62 | Shenandoah | 74 | Final - OT | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| Dec. 17 | Bridgewater (Va.) | 69 | Ferrum | 71 | Final | Box Recap | |
| Greensboro | 74 | Emory | 88 | Final | Box Box Recap | ||
| Hampden-Sydney | 55 | Averett | 70 | Final | Recap | ||
| Dec. 18 | Wesley | 80 | Chris. Newport | 68 | Final | Box Box Recap | |
| Dec. 19 | Ferrum | Winston-Salem | 4:00 PM | ||||
| Dec. 29 | Averett | 64 | St. Mary's (Md.) | 69 | Final | Box Recap Recap | |
| The Car Coop/Weenie Miller Memorial Holiday Hoops @ Hampden-Sydney | |||||||
| Trine | 70 | Shenandoah | 68 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Dec. 30 | John Jay | 57 | Averett | 76 | Final | ||
| @ Hampden-Sydney | |||||||
| Ferrum | 62 | Washington and Lee | 76 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Lycoming | 78 | Shenandoah | 67 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Jan. 2 | LaGrange | 84 | Methodist | 76 | Final | ||
| Averett | 69 | Lynchburg | 71 | Final - OT | |||
| Defiance | 87 | Ferrum | 85 | Final | Box Recap Recap | ||
| @ Domino's New Year's Classic (Salem, Va.) | |||||||
| Westfield St. | 60 | Chris. Newport | 77 | Final | |||
| Jan. 3 | Ferrum | 78 | Roanoke | 70 | Final | Box Recap | |
| Morris Cregger Invitational | |||||||
| York (N.Y.) | 71 | Chris. Newport | 61 | Final - OT | Box | ||
| Methodist | 90 | Piedmont | 111 | Final | |||
| Jan. 4 | N.C. Wesleyan | 75 | LaGrange | 69 | Final | ||
| Jan. 5 | N.C. Wesleyan | 79 | Piedmont | 88 | Final | ||
| Jan. 6 | Greensboro | 78 | Maryville (Tenn.) | 93 | Final | ||
| Chris. Newport | 60 | Shenandoah | 62 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Ferrum | 51 | Averett | 69 | Final | |||
| Jan. 9 | Methodist | 58 | Ferrum | 75 | Final | ||
| Shenandoah | 79 | N.C. Wesleyan | 97 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Greensboro | 60 | Averett | 58 | Final | |||
| Chris. Newport | 68 | Randolph-Macon | 80 | Final | Box Recap Recap | ||
| Jan. 11 | Concord | 79 | Greensboro | 88 | Final | ||
| Jan. 12 | Shenandoah | 79 | Southern Va. | 93 | Final | Box Box Box Box Recap Recap | |
| Jan. 13 | N.C. Wesleyan | 79 | Chris. Newport | 89 | Final | ||
| Averett | 85 | Methodist | 64 | Final | |||
| Ferrum | 82 | Greensboro | 78 | Final - OT | |||
| Jan. 16 | Methodist | 59 | Lynchburg | 93 | Final | ||
| Shenandoah | 68 | Ferrum | 63 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| N.C. Wesleyan | 74 | Greensboro | 70 | Final | |||
| Chris. Newport | 72 | Averett | 88 | Final | |||
| Jan. 17 | Shenandoah | 64 | Averett | 62 | Final | Box Box Recap | |
| Chris. Newport | 74 | Ferrum | 60 | Final | |||
| Jan. 18 | Greensboro | 70 | Randolph | 62 | Final | ||
| Methodist | 71 | N.C. Wesleyan | 84 | Final | |||
| Jan. 20 | Washington and Lee | 59 | Methodist | 53 | Final | Box Recap | |
| Averett | 57 | Ferrum | 59 | Final | |||
| Jan. 23 | Methodist | 65 | Chris. Newport | 83 | Final | ||
| Greensboro | 79 | Shenandoah | 73 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Averett | 69 | N.C. Wesleyan | 82 | Final | |||
| Jan. 24 | Methodist | 98 | Shenandoah | 113 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| Greensboro | 67 | Chris. Newport | 76 | Final | |||
| Jan. 27 | Shenandoah | 65 | Chris. Newport | 62 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| N.C. Wesleyan | 100 | Ferrum | 90 | Final | |||
| Jan. 29 | Greensboro | 70 | Methodist | 98 | Final | ||
| Feb. 1 | Ferrum | 74 | Methodist | 80 | Final | ||
| Averett | 69 | Greensboro | 63 | Final | |||
| Feb. 2 | N.C. Wesleyan | 79 | Shenandoah | 71 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| St. Mary's (Md.) | 91 | Chris. Newport | 82 | Final - OT | Box Recap Recap | ||
| Feb. 4 | Ferrum | 49 | Winston-Salem | 62 | Final | ||
| Feb. 6 | Chris. Newport | 80 | N.C. Wesleyan | 90 | Final | ||
| Methodist | 69 | Averett | 84 | Final | |||
| Feb. 8 | Methodist | 70 | Charleston (W.V.) | 100 | Final | ||
| Bridgewater (Va.) | 68 | Averett | 56 | Final | Box Recap | ||
| Rescheduled from January 30 | |||||||
| Greensboro | 68 | Ferrum | 70 | Final | |||
| Feb. 10 | Greensboro | 78 | N.C. Wesleyan | 79 | Final | ||
| Averett | 90 | Chris. Newport | 84 | Final | |||
| Feb. 11 | Ferrum | 58 | Shenandoah | 64 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| Feb. 13 | N.C. Wesleyan | 93 | Methodist | 63 | Final | ||
| Averett | 66 | Shenandoah | 71 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Feb. 14 | Ferrum | 58 | Chris. Newport | 61 | Final | ||
| Feb. 16 | N.C. Wesleyan | 90 | Averett | 80 | Final | ||
| Methodist | 73 | Greensboro | 92 | Final | |||
| Feb. 19 | Chris. Newport | 70 | Greensboro | 68 | Final - OT | ||
| Shenandoah | 76 | Methodist | 78 | Final - OT | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Feb. 20 | Chris. Newport | 76 | Methodist | 70 | Final | ||
| Ferrum | 77 | N.C. Wesleyan | 92 | Final | |||
| Shenandoah | 54 | Greensboro | 56 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| Feb. 23 | Methodist | 56 | Shenandoah | 60 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | |
| USA South Quarterfinals | |||||||
| Greensboro | 60 | Chris. Newport | 73 | Final | |||
| USA South Tournament - First Round | |||||||
| Ferrum | 62 | Averett | 73 | Final | |||
| USA South Tournament - First Round | |||||||
| Feb. 26 | Averett | 70 | N.C. Wesleyan | 90 | Final | ||
| USA South Tournament - Semifinals @ Newport News, Virginia | |||||||
| Shenandoah | 69 | Chris. Newport | 82 | Final | Box Box Recap Recap | ||
| USA South Semi-Finals at CNU | |||||||
| Feb. 27 | N.C. Wesleyan | 63 | Chris. Newport | 67 | Final | ||
| USA South Tournament Championship | |||||||
| Mar. 5 | Chris. Newport | 59 | Guilford | 83 | Final | Box Box Box Recap Recap | |
| 1st Round NCAA Tournament | |||||||







